--> Best Online Share Trading Company in Indore

About Us
Help Desk
Contact Us
Sign In
  • Home
  • blogs
  • Why is mixing insurance & investments a bad idea?

Why is mixing insurance & investments a bad idea?

Insurance And Investments

Imagine you're enjoying a plate of piping hot Indore chaat. Now, picture someone sprinkling a handful of jalebis on top, Sounds messy, right? Well, that's what happens when you mix insurance and investments – two crucial financial tools with distinct purposes. While both play important roles in your financial well-being, keeping them separate is key to achieving your goals. So, let's untangle the journey of insurance and investments.

What is the difference between Insurance and Investment?

These are some of the key differences between insurance and investment from a financial perspective. Each serves different purposes and plays distinct roles in an individual's or organisation's financial planning.






Think of insurance as your safety net, a protective shield against life's unexpected twists and turns. It provides financial support in case of accidents, illnesses, or even death, ensuring your loved ones are cared for. 

Investments, on the other hand, are like seeds you plant, hoping they'll grow into a bountiful harvest. They aim to increase your wealth over time through growth in stock prices, dividends, or other means.


The primary purpose of insurance is to provide financial protection against specific risks, such as health issues, accidents, or death. It offers a payout (benefit) in case the insured event occurs.

Investments are made with the goal of generating a return on the capital invested. The focus is on growing wealth over time through various financial instruments such as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, etc.

Risk Management

It is a risk management tool that helps individuals and businesses mitigate potential financial losses due to unforeseen events.

Investments involve varying degrees of risk, and the goal is to manage and potentially grow wealth over time.

Return on Capital

Premiums paid for insurance policies do not typically generate a direct financial return. The benefit comes in the form of protection against loss.

The primary aim of investments is to generate a financial return, which can come in the form of interest, dividends, or capital appreciation.

Time Horizon

Insurance is typically focused on short to long-term protection, with benefits paid out in the event of specific contingencies.

investments can have short, medium, or long-term time horizons, depending on the specific investment vehicle and the investor's goals.


Insurance policies generally do not offer liquidity in the same way that traditional investments do. They are designed for specific contingencies and are not easily liquidated for cash value.

Many investment vehicles offer liquidity, allowing investors to buy and sell assets relatively quickly to access cash if needed.


Why Insurance and Investment shouldn't be mixed?

Like oil and water, insurance and investments have very different goals and functionalities. Mixing them up can lead to several problems such as:

Misaligned Goals 

Imagine wanting to buy a dream house in 5 years and investing in a life insurance policy with a 20-year maturity. While the insurance provides cover, it locks away your money for too long, hindering your short-term goal. Remember, insurance protects while investments grow.

Confusing Returns 

Insurance policies come with guaranteed returns, but they're usually lower than potential investment returns. Mixing both can make it tricky to track your actual investment performance and achieve your desired growth.

Limited Flexibility

Many insurance policies have surrender charges or lock-in periods, restricting your access to your money when you might need it for an emergency. Investments, like mutual funds, offer more flexibility to withdraw or reallocate funds based on your needs.

Hidden Costs

Some insurance policies with investment components might have higher charges or fees than standalone investment options. Compare and analyse costs carefully before mixing the two.

Are there any situations where  mixing insurance & investments is okay?

Very few scenarios exist where mixing insurance and investments makes sense. For instance, some unit-linked insurance plans (ULIPs) combine insurance coverage with market-linked investments. However, these can be complex and come with higher charges. Always weigh the pros and cons, and consult a financial advisor before considering such products.

Right approach to manage Investment and Insurance

Treat insurance and investments as separate dishes on your financial plate.

Prioritise your needs:Identify your goals – protection or growth? Ensure you have adequate insurance coverage first, protecting your loved ones from any financial burden.

Build a diversified portfolio: Once your insurance needs are met, explore various investment options like mutual funds, stocks, or bonds based on your risk tolerance and time horizon.

Seek professional guidance: Don't hesitate to consult a reliable share broker or financial advisor who can assess your situation and recommend suitable products and strategies.


Just like keeping your chaat plate organised separates the tangy chutney from the sweet jalebis, keeping insurance and investments distinct ensures each serves its purpose perfectly. By understanding their different roles, prioritising your needs, and making informed choices, you can create a robust financial tapestry, woven with the threads of secure protection and steady growth. Remember, a healthy financial plate has insurance for security and investments for prosperity – savor each element carefully, and watch your financial future blossom!

Frequently Asked Questions:

Q: I already have a mixed insurance-investment product. What should I do?

A: Consult a financial advisor to assess your existing policy and explore possible alternatives or adjustments to better align your insurance and investment strategies.


Q: Can't I just buy a single product that does both insurance and investments?

A: While some products offer both, they might not be optimal for everyone. Research the fees, risks, and limitations of such products before investing.


Q: How much insurance coverage do I actually need?

A: Your insurance needs depend on your income, dependents, liabilities, and lifestyle. Use online calculators or consult an advisor to assess your personal requirement.


Related Blogs

Issued in the interest of investors: Prevent Unauthorised transactions in your trading and Demat account. Update your mobile numbers/email IDs with Tradingbells. Receive alerts and information of all debit and other important transactions in your trading and Demat account directly from Exchange/Depository on your mobile/email at the end of the day. KYC is a onetime exercise while dealing in securities markets. Once KYC is done through a SEBI registered intermediary (broker, DP, Mutual Fund etc.), you need not undergo the same process again when you approach another intermediary.

No need to issue cheques by investors while subscribing to IPO. Just write the bank account number and sign in the application form to authorise your bank to make payment in case of allotment. No worries of refund as money remains in investor's account.

2021-22, TradingBells All rights reserved